Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Beaudrot's Rule

I completely agree with this tweet from Nick Beaudrot (quite appropriate shouting is his)::
The first rule of 2012 General election polling is DO NOT TALK ABOUT GENERAL ELECTION POLLING UNTIL THE GENERAL cc @daveweigel
Which was a response to Weigel's:
Obama leads potential GOP prez candidates by 5-10 points in Virginia. #demsindisarray #pagingdougschoen http://slate.me/d2resL
If you want to know about Barack Obama's chances in 2012, I recommend two things: pay attention to his approval ratings, and pay attention to the economic results and forecasts.  Really, you can completely, totally, absolutely ignore head-to-head polling matchups until Labor Day, 2012.  I know, we won't, but I'll strongly urge everyone to pay no attention to such polling until at least the GOP candidate is chosen.

3 comments:

  1. Ah, but what about comparative matchups?

    Naturally, we only have the results for polling after the primary, and in the presidential case, there's like 9 months between primary and election day.

    But, if Candidate A beats candidates B and C in matchups, but not D, doesn't that indicate something about D versus B & C? Not predictive of the general, but suggestive about individual candidates?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm gonna say...you're not going to get much out of those. This early, you're going to get a lot of name recognition -- and you may get that well into the primary season.

    If I were trying to figure out which candidate matched up best against the other party, I would probably pay attention to favorable/unfavorable much more than to head-to-head matchups. Beyond polling, it's generally a safe bet that ideological extremism doesn't play well, and you could also look for signs of coalition-building skills rather than faction mobilization.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I tend to agree but I still can't help but think this is good news for President Obama. You just suffered a massive mid-term defeat after a year of 9+ unemployment and you are still leading your nearest rivals in a purplish state that looked like it was trending away from you. I would not have expected that.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.