Same one that I did for conservatives: who was your rookie of the year for the first session of Congress? Of those first elected in 2012, who impressed you?
(Fine. I know you all are going to say Elizabeth Warren. So if you have runner-up, add that one, too).
Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts
Sunday, January 5, 2014
Sunday Question for Conservatives
Looking back on the first session of Congress -- who is your rookie of the year? Who is the best of those newly elected in 2012?
Wednesday, December 11, 2013
Read Stuff. You Should
Happy Birthday to McCoy Tyner, 75.
Tons of news yesterday, but you'll still want the good stuff:
1. Mann and Ornstein want to save Congress.
2. Lynn Vavreck reviews Double Down.
3. John Sides on the Steve Stockman challenge.
4. Scott Lemieux is a little obsessed with liberal health care reform fantasies...but he's also totally correct.
5. And Sarah Kliff provides a user guide to the ACA and Healthcare.gov.
Tons of news yesterday, but you'll still want the good stuff:
1. Mann and Ornstein want to save Congress.
2. Lynn Vavreck reviews Double Down.
3. John Sides on the Steve Stockman challenge.
4. Scott Lemieux is a little obsessed with liberal health care reform fantasies...but he's also totally correct.
5. And Sarah Kliff provides a user guide to the ACA and Healthcare.gov.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Gridlock/Polarization
National Journal is running a funny-looking chart of partisan polarization in the House with this explanation:
Second: polarization -- partisan polarization -- just means that Members vote with their party and against theother party. Gridlock is about failure to pass legislation. Indeed, really more specific; to go back to the traffic analogy, it's about failure to pass legislation that everyone wants, but is being blocked by collective action failure of some type.
Which is to say that gridlock and polarization are not the same thing, and not necessarily related in any straightforward way.
Indeed, within the House, partisan polarization should ease gridlock. Since the House runs by majority party, if that party is unified, then they can basically do whatever they want.
Thus in the historic 111th Congress, in 2009-2010, the House was extremely productive. Very strong polarization, and no gridlock at all.
The Senate, with the filibuster forcing supermajorities, is another story; there, polarization might make gridlock more likely assuming that the majority party has fewer than 60 Senators. However, with 60 Senators, and given unified government, polarization should mean less, not more, gridock.
What about with divided government? Does polarization then mean gridlock?
Not necessarily. A non-polarized Congress can avoid gridlock by having different majorities express themselves on different issues. On the other hand, a non-polarized Congress also can create a lot more gridlock. After all, a polarized Congress means that one person can bargain for her whole party; a non-polarized Congress can devolve into an ungovernable mess (indeed, one theory of why parties exist at all is that legislatures don't really work well without them).
In other words, the relationship between polarization and gridlock is complicated.
What does cause gridlock, however, is a party driven by aversion to compromise -- both internally and with the other party. That's what's happening now, with the dysfunctional GOP. And that, not polarization, is most likely the primary source of current gridlock.
If you're looking for a quick fact to explain congressional gridlock, it's this: In the 113th Congress, only 59 members have voted with the majority of their party less than 90 percent of the time (20 Republicans and 39 Democrats).So first of all, a minor point: "Congress" here apparently means the House.
Second: polarization -- partisan polarization -- just means that Members vote with their party and against theother party. Gridlock is about failure to pass legislation. Indeed, really more specific; to go back to the traffic analogy, it's about failure to pass legislation that everyone wants, but is being blocked by collective action failure of some type.
Which is to say that gridlock and polarization are not the same thing, and not necessarily related in any straightforward way.
Indeed, within the House, partisan polarization should ease gridlock. Since the House runs by majority party, if that party is unified, then they can basically do whatever they want.
Thus in the historic 111th Congress, in 2009-2010, the House was extremely productive. Very strong polarization, and no gridlock at all.
The Senate, with the filibuster forcing supermajorities, is another story; there, polarization might make gridlock more likely assuming that the majority party has fewer than 60 Senators. However, with 60 Senators, and given unified government, polarization should mean less, not more, gridock.
What about with divided government? Does polarization then mean gridlock?
Not necessarily. A non-polarized Congress can avoid gridlock by having different majorities express themselves on different issues. On the other hand, a non-polarized Congress also can create a lot more gridlock. After all, a polarized Congress means that one person can bargain for her whole party; a non-polarized Congress can devolve into an ungovernable mess (indeed, one theory of why parties exist at all is that legislatures don't really work well without them).
In other words, the relationship between polarization and gridlock is complicated.
What does cause gridlock, however, is a party driven by aversion to compromise -- both internally and with the other party. That's what's happening now, with the dysfunctional GOP. And that, not polarization, is most likely the primary source of current gridlock.
Thursday, October 24, 2013
Quick Oversight Hearing Primer
I'm not watching the big House Obamacare oversight hearing this morning, but half my twitter stream is, and we've reached the point in which they're complaining that we're not going to learn anything.
Here's why they are actually very useful. Even when they're boring.
Time for a quick primer. Congressional oversight hearings are mostly useful because they exist. The actual hearing itself? Not much usually happens. But the threat of being called to account, and then the process of being called to account, should and probably does put pressure on executive branch agencies and departments. That's a good thing!
There's also a part of it which is just getting everyone on record in a formal setting. That's not going to be very informative, usually, at least for attentive observers, since all anyone is going to do is to confirm what's already out there. But there really is some utility to having these things on record, officially out of the mouths of those who are supposed to be getting things done.
Remember that this is part of separated institutions sharing powers; oversight hearings are one tool Congress has to compete over who gets to execute the laws, and how those laws will be executed. So the public part can be very bland but still be a key part of bullying bureaucrats, administration officials, and outside contractors (among other things, a bland hearing can be their reward for being bullied).
Moreover, since the public testimony might be irrelevant to the point of having the hearing, individual committee members can use the time for producing clips that can run on local TV news shows. Every once in a while that will make good TV, but usually not. Don't forget; the witnesses usually have an interest in not making news, and so if they're smart they'll leak things out beforehand in order to better manage the spin. Which again might make the actual hearing boring even if it's been successful in generating information that would otherwise have remained unavailable.
Conclusion: if everyone does their job properly, most oversight hearings will be both (1) boring, uninformative (especially to beat reporters who know the subject) occasions for the worst self-aggrandizing politician behavior; and, (2) a highly useful and functional part of the process of separated institutions sharing powers.
Here's why they are actually very useful. Even when they're boring.
Time for a quick primer. Congressional oversight hearings are mostly useful because they exist. The actual hearing itself? Not much usually happens. But the threat of being called to account, and then the process of being called to account, should and probably does put pressure on executive branch agencies and departments. That's a good thing!
There's also a part of it which is just getting everyone on record in a formal setting. That's not going to be very informative, usually, at least for attentive observers, since all anyone is going to do is to confirm what's already out there. But there really is some utility to having these things on record, officially out of the mouths of those who are supposed to be getting things done.
Remember that this is part of separated institutions sharing powers; oversight hearings are one tool Congress has to compete over who gets to execute the laws, and how those laws will be executed. So the public part can be very bland but still be a key part of bullying bureaucrats, administration officials, and outside contractors (among other things, a bland hearing can be their reward for being bullied).
Moreover, since the public testimony might be irrelevant to the point of having the hearing, individual committee members can use the time for producing clips that can run on local TV news shows. Every once in a while that will make good TV, but usually not. Don't forget; the witnesses usually have an interest in not making news, and so if they're smart they'll leak things out beforehand in order to better manage the spin. Which again might make the actual hearing boring even if it's been successful in generating information that would otherwise have remained unavailable.
Conclusion: if everyone does their job properly, most oversight hearings will be both (1) boring, uninformative (especially to beat reporters who know the subject) occasions for the worst self-aggrandizing politician behavior; and, (2) a highly useful and functional part of the process of separated institutions sharing powers.
Wednesday, October 16, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to David Greenwalt, 64.
Some good stuff:
1. Joshua Huder with the case that it's internal Congressional incentives, rules, and procedures that produce the extreme polarization we're seeing. I have no argument with that; however, I'll note that the presidency, too, has become far more partisan than it has been. Regulars know what I think: strong parties, including strong party networks, are a significant factors in all of this.
2. I don't think that Ross Douthat's argument about the radicals and policy really holds up...but it's worth taking seriously.
3. Medicare Advantage is doing just fine? That's what Kate Pickert reports.
4. More from Ray La Raja on campaign finance.
5. And Dan Drezner on a potential Marx comeback in political economy. I can't really speak to that, I guess; I think of Marx as an important political theorist, but weak on economics.
Some good stuff:
1. Joshua Huder with the case that it's internal Congressional incentives, rules, and procedures that produce the extreme polarization we're seeing. I have no argument with that; however, I'll note that the presidency, too, has become far more partisan than it has been. Regulars know what I think: strong parties, including strong party networks, are a significant factors in all of this.
2. I don't think that Ross Douthat's argument about the radicals and policy really holds up...but it's worth taking seriously.
3. Medicare Advantage is doing just fine? That's what Kate Pickert reports.
4. More from Ray La Raja on campaign finance.
5. And Dan Drezner on a potential Marx comeback in political economy. I can't really speak to that, I guess; I think of Marx as an important political theorist, but weak on economics.
Friday, October 4, 2013
Procedure and the Politics of Procedure
Sarah Binder took another look at why discharge petitions are rarely useful, and why that procedure isn't going to solve the current shutdown.
She's certainly correct, and Greg Sargent's post about defeating the "previous question" is part of the reason why: if dissenting Republicans are willing to go against the party on procedural votes, they have a much easier way of doing it than a discharge petition. However, as Dave Weigel makes clear, Republican clean CR supporters aren't close to voting against the party on procedural votes.
(Just as I was almost done with this...Greg now reports that Democrats may work a discharge petition on a "automatic CR" bill some Republican had filed a while ago. It would speed up the process, but it's still not clear why it's a better procedure than using the previous question -- why would Republicans not willing to do the latter sign the former? It seems more like a talking point than real procedural plan).
Greg talks about how dissenting Democrats worked with the Reagan White House in 1981 to use this procedure. But remember: the Democrats involved in that fight were not even remotely similar to the clean CR Republicans today. It's not just the ideological positions involved; today's GOP dissenters are moderate by House Republican standards, but they're all more conservative than any House Democrat, while the Democrats involved in 1981 were far more conservative than many Republicans of the time. It's also the question of party loyalty. Conservative Democrats in 1981 were active, open, opponents of "national" Democrats, and I suspect that many of them eventually became Republicans anyway. Certainly, their leader, then-Democrat Phil Gramm of Texas, would soon resign his House seat, run again as a Republican and win election, and eventually become a Senator and a presidential candidate as a Republican.
More generally, in those weaker-party days, the "conservative coalition" in the House of Republicans and Southern Democrats had long worked together. That had faded by 1981 -- the real peak of the coalition was in the late 1930s through the 1950s -- but it was still possible to revive it. There's nothing remotely close to that today; if Republican moderates betrayed their party on procedural votes, it would be something new and unprecedented for them.
Not that they couldn't do it! But the norms of Congress certainly have been that defecting on substantive votes isn't nearly as big a deal as defecting on procedural votes.
And this fight shows exactly why that is. As usual, there are multiple possible winning coalitions on the House floor -- in this case, there's a GOP-only group that's voted for a number of things, but there's also a mostly-Democrats coalition that supports a clean CR. Indeed: we know there are 217 votes for a CR-plus-defunding, a CR-plus-delaying, a CR-plus-delaying the individual mandate, and reportedly a clean CR; there may well be majorities for a clean CR at various different funding levels, and for a CR with various other add-ons. The whole strength of having the party majority is that the party gets to choose which of those things actually comes up for a vote. Once Members treat procedural votes as if they were substantive votes, then the party is worthless (and, beyond that, you get chaos -- because there's no way to regulate which of the many possible majorities gets votes).
By the way, that's why the Hastert Rule is quite normal and logical: of course the majority party is going to regulate which things get to the House floor, and doing it by majority is perfectly sensible when possible. The real questions are what to do when it isn't possible, not why you would have that "rule" in the first place.
So: the reason why I've harped on the idea that you need plenty of public dissenting Republicans before it puts real pressure on Boehner is precisely because there's little chance that just 17 Republicans would defect on such a huge issue and on a procedural vote. However, the larger the group gets -- and since we're told that the public dissenters are only the tip of the iceberg -- the more the iceberg, as it were, starts to matter. And, at the same time, the pressure on the public dissenters to actually do something about it grows stronger.
However, as of now, the number seems to have stalled short of 25 (we'll see what the weekend does for that). It's no surprise that if that's all that are willing to go public on substance that we're nowhere near having enough to actually betray their party on procedure.
The bottom line is that however it's expressed in a a final vote, this is unlikely to end because 17 or 18 or 21 Republicans work with Democrats, and against the real wishes of the rest of their party. It is possible that a final vote will work out that way, but only if that's what the bulk of the conference wants. And if that happens, the key vote will be almost certainly be on substance, not bucking the party on procedure.
She's certainly correct, and Greg Sargent's post about defeating the "previous question" is part of the reason why: if dissenting Republicans are willing to go against the party on procedural votes, they have a much easier way of doing it than a discharge petition. However, as Dave Weigel makes clear, Republican clean CR supporters aren't close to voting against the party on procedural votes.
(Just as I was almost done with this...Greg now reports that Democrats may work a discharge petition on a "automatic CR" bill some Republican had filed a while ago. It would speed up the process, but it's still not clear why it's a better procedure than using the previous question -- why would Republicans not willing to do the latter sign the former? It seems more like a talking point than real procedural plan).
Greg talks about how dissenting Democrats worked with the Reagan White House in 1981 to use this procedure. But remember: the Democrats involved in that fight were not even remotely similar to the clean CR Republicans today. It's not just the ideological positions involved; today's GOP dissenters are moderate by House Republican standards, but they're all more conservative than any House Democrat, while the Democrats involved in 1981 were far more conservative than many Republicans of the time. It's also the question of party loyalty. Conservative Democrats in 1981 were active, open, opponents of "national" Democrats, and I suspect that many of them eventually became Republicans anyway. Certainly, their leader, then-Democrat Phil Gramm of Texas, would soon resign his House seat, run again as a Republican and win election, and eventually become a Senator and a presidential candidate as a Republican.
More generally, in those weaker-party days, the "conservative coalition" in the House of Republicans and Southern Democrats had long worked together. That had faded by 1981 -- the real peak of the coalition was in the late 1930s through the 1950s -- but it was still possible to revive it. There's nothing remotely close to that today; if Republican moderates betrayed their party on procedural votes, it would be something new and unprecedented for them.
Not that they couldn't do it! But the norms of Congress certainly have been that defecting on substantive votes isn't nearly as big a deal as defecting on procedural votes.
And this fight shows exactly why that is. As usual, there are multiple possible winning coalitions on the House floor -- in this case, there's a GOP-only group that's voted for a number of things, but there's also a mostly-Democrats coalition that supports a clean CR. Indeed: we know there are 217 votes for a CR-plus-defunding, a CR-plus-delaying, a CR-plus-delaying the individual mandate, and reportedly a clean CR; there may well be majorities for a clean CR at various different funding levels, and for a CR with various other add-ons. The whole strength of having the party majority is that the party gets to choose which of those things actually comes up for a vote. Once Members treat procedural votes as if they were substantive votes, then the party is worthless (and, beyond that, you get chaos -- because there's no way to regulate which of the many possible majorities gets votes).
By the way, that's why the Hastert Rule is quite normal and logical: of course the majority party is going to regulate which things get to the House floor, and doing it by majority is perfectly sensible when possible. The real questions are what to do when it isn't possible, not why you would have that "rule" in the first place.
So: the reason why I've harped on the idea that you need plenty of public dissenting Republicans before it puts real pressure on Boehner is precisely because there's little chance that just 17 Republicans would defect on such a huge issue and on a procedural vote. However, the larger the group gets -- and since we're told that the public dissenters are only the tip of the iceberg -- the more the iceberg, as it were, starts to matter. And, at the same time, the pressure on the public dissenters to actually do something about it grows stronger.
However, as of now, the number seems to have stalled short of 25 (we'll see what the weekend does for that). It's no surprise that if that's all that are willing to go public on substance that we're nowhere near having enough to actually betray their party on procedure.
The bottom line is that however it's expressed in a a final vote, this is unlikely to end because 17 or 18 or 21 Republicans work with Democrats, and against the real wishes of the rest of their party. It is possible that a final vote will work out that way, but only if that's what the bulk of the conference wants. And if that happens, the key vote will be almost certainly be on substance, not bucking the party on procedure.
Wednesday, October 2, 2013
Mystical Procedural Stuff and Weird Obsessions
Here's the thing. Sarah Binder wrote a nice explanation over at the all-new and WaPo-ified Monkey Cage of why discharge petitions weren't going to work to end the shutdown. Then a bit later, Steve Pearlstein, who is usually very good, wrote at Wonkblog why a discharge petition might do the trick.
Sarah is correct. But it's not going to slow anyone down, which pushed me to ask:
Michael Cohen:
Silver bullet explanations for larger, institutional and intractable public policy challenges
Liam Liwanag Burke:
Great man/American Hero theory of governance causes cognitive dissonance when dealing with actual rules of order
Matt Glassman:
They play into conspiracy theories of ideologues; it's not that opposition is nearly as popular, it's that they cheat and our leaders are soft.
So that's what they said. What do you think? Other ideas? I'm definitely curious about everyone's reactions.
Sarah is correct. But it's not going to slow anyone down, which pushed me to ask:
Someone needs to explain to me the weird fixation on mystical powers of: gerrymandering; talking filibusters; discharge petitionsAnd out of a few replies, I thought these three were worth sharing. I'm not sure any of them are "the" answer, or if there is any particular answer, or even if it's the right question...perhaps it just seems to me that these three things are grouped together. But at any rate, here are the best answers I received (edited to remove the twitter from them).
Michael Cohen:
Silver bullet explanations for larger, institutional and intractable public policy challenges
Liam Liwanag Burke:
Great man/American Hero theory of governance causes cognitive dissonance when dealing with actual rules of order
Matt Glassman:
They play into conspiracy theories of ideologues; it's not that opposition is nearly as popular, it's that they cheat and our leaders are soft.
So that's what they said. What do you think? Other ideas? I'm definitely curious about everyone's reactions.
Monday, September 30, 2013
Could It Be An All-Night Ping Pong Party in Congress?
So far today, the Senate tabled the CR version that the House passed Saturday night, and House Republicans are meeting and reportedly are going to pass a third version of their anti-Obamacare CR.
Reporters are tweeting that Republicans are coming out of their meeting a lot less enthusiastic than they were on Saturday. They surely know that their new CR is DOA in the Senate; perhaps they intend to pass this one, have it get sent back again, and then surrender. Perhaps they can't even hold together for one more futile round.
But maybe not!
Which brings up one possibility.
Both sides seem to believe that there's a spin advantage if their side is the most recent one to act. All day yesterday, Republicans were complaining about the Senate not working on Sunday when the House had (supposedly) done their job. No doubt if the House quit for the day right now, with the ball on their side of the Capitol, Democrats would complain that the House wasn't working while the government shut down.
So unless I'm missing something in the parliamentary situation -- maybe Steve Smith or Sarah Binder could correct me if I'm wrong -- we might actually get an all-night ping-pong.
The Senate was able to table the House amendments and sent it back in basically no time at all (mainly the time for the vote) this afternoon (the parliamentary procedures here are beyond my expertise, but that's what happened). Presumably, the same thing will be the case the next time, too. And the one after that. And after that.
The House, I believe, needs a bit more time...I'm guessing that it's a good three, four hours for them to get from deciding on a next move to final passage; that's not counting whatever time they need for a meeting to decide that next step. Still, I'm writing this at 3:30 in the afternoon DC time...if they finish this one at dinner time, they could do another at midnight when the government technically shuts down (hey, they can claim for as long as it lasts that they acted and the Senate didn't) and maybe get two more rounds in before the federal work day starts. Or doesn't start. Maybe they could compress it even more, and squeeze in a couple more rounds, although it does seem to me that they need to draft amendments, get a rule from the Rules Committee, then get the rule passed, and then pass the amendment(s) and get final passage, and that sure seems like three or four hours minimum to me.
All night ping-pong? I'm not quite predicting it, but it wouldn't surprise me at this point.
Reporters are tweeting that Republicans are coming out of their meeting a lot less enthusiastic than they were on Saturday. They surely know that their new CR is DOA in the Senate; perhaps they intend to pass this one, have it get sent back again, and then surrender. Perhaps they can't even hold together for one more futile round.
But maybe not!
Which brings up one possibility.
Both sides seem to believe that there's a spin advantage if their side is the most recent one to act. All day yesterday, Republicans were complaining about the Senate not working on Sunday when the House had (supposedly) done their job. No doubt if the House quit for the day right now, with the ball on their side of the Capitol, Democrats would complain that the House wasn't working while the government shut down.
So unless I'm missing something in the parliamentary situation -- maybe Steve Smith or Sarah Binder could correct me if I'm wrong -- we might actually get an all-night ping-pong.
The Senate was able to table the House amendments and sent it back in basically no time at all (mainly the time for the vote) this afternoon (the parliamentary procedures here are beyond my expertise, but that's what happened). Presumably, the same thing will be the case the next time, too. And the one after that. And after that.
The House, I believe, needs a bit more time...I'm guessing that it's a good three, four hours for them to get from deciding on a next move to final passage; that's not counting whatever time they need for a meeting to decide that next step. Still, I'm writing this at 3:30 in the afternoon DC time...if they finish this one at dinner time, they could do another at midnight when the government technically shuts down (hey, they can claim for as long as it lasts that they acted and the Senate didn't) and maybe get two more rounds in before the federal work day starts. Or doesn't start. Maybe they could compress it even more, and squeeze in a couple more rounds, although it does seem to me that they need to draft amendments, get a rule from the Rules Committee, then get the rule passed, and then pass the amendment(s) and get final passage, and that sure seems like three or four hours minimum to me.
All night ping-pong? I'm not quite predicting it, but it wouldn't surprise me at this point.
Tuesday, September 24, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Megan Ward, 44. I'm sure people who didn't go to Wesleyan can enjoy PCU; just not sure I get why they would.
The good stuff:
Here's good news: Thomas is being phased out.
Good news for racing? Hey, that is good news. Lydia DePillis on higher yearling sales prices as a sign of economic recovery. Yes, I know that most (okay, almost all) of you don't care.
Emma Roller on Ted Cruz, college debater. Double-extra warning: we know how memory works, or doesn't work. We know how partisanship works. It's highly likely that liberals remembering Ted Cruz from years ago would be either highly selective, or even fairly inaccurate, in their memories -- with their memories matching their current view of Cruz as a jerk. Might he have actually been a jerk? It's certainly possible. Is he a jerk now? I have no idea, and neither do any of you who don't hang out with him regularly. "Work jerk" isn't the same as personal jerk, no matter how much our rational minds resist that idea.
The good stuff:
Here's good news: Thomas is being phased out.
Good news for racing? Hey, that is good news. Lydia DePillis on higher yearling sales prices as a sign of economic recovery. Yes, I know that most (okay, almost all) of you don't care.
Emma Roller on Ted Cruz, college debater. Double-extra warning: we know how memory works, or doesn't work. We know how partisanship works. It's highly likely that liberals remembering Ted Cruz from years ago would be either highly selective, or even fairly inaccurate, in their memories -- with their memories matching their current view of Cruz as a jerk. Might he have actually been a jerk? It's certainly possible. Is he a jerk now? I have no idea, and neither do any of you who don't hang out with him regularly. "Work jerk" isn't the same as personal jerk, no matter how much our rational minds resist that idea.
Monday, September 23, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Rosalind Chao, 56.
Good stuff for the new week:
1. I'm really looking forward to reading Steve Teles on "Kludgeocracy in America."
2. If you're following the CR and the Senate, then Sarah Binder's piece on procedure is a must-read.
3. Another good one from Dan Drezner on Syria and Iran.
4. David Price (the political scientist and Member of the House, not the pitcher) on the broken appropriations process.
5. And a nice one from John Sides and Lynn Vavreck; it's an excerpt from their new book on 2012, with this piece covering the post-South Carolina primaries and caucuses. It's excellent (despite an unfortunate headline that Salon stuck them with, which suggests exactly the opposite of what their analysis says). Looking back, I'm more convinced than ever that Romney wrapped it up in South Carolina -- it knocked Rick Perry out, and put the vaguely viable Rick Santorum too far behind to really have any serious chance even if everything broke right for him.
Good stuff for the new week:
1. I'm really looking forward to reading Steve Teles on "Kludgeocracy in America."
2. If you're following the CR and the Senate, then Sarah Binder's piece on procedure is a must-read.
3. Another good one from Dan Drezner on Syria and Iran.
4. David Price (the political scientist and Member of the House, not the pitcher) on the broken appropriations process.
5. And a nice one from John Sides and Lynn Vavreck; it's an excerpt from their new book on 2012, with this piece covering the post-South Carolina primaries and caucuses. It's excellent (despite an unfortunate headline that Salon stuck them with, which suggests exactly the opposite of what their analysis says). Looking back, I'm more convinced than ever that Romney wrapped it up in South Carolina -- it knocked Rick Perry out, and put the vaguely viable Rick Santorum too far behind to really have any serious chance even if everything broke right for him.
Wednesday, September 11, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Ellis Burks, 49. Not quite a HOFer...but a lot closer than you might think, and better than quite a few guys who made it. Terrific late hitting second peak, ages 34-37, but only about 250 PAs after that.
Plenty of good stuff:
1. Excellent new TNR feature: Isaac Chotiner tries to interview Barney Frank, receives abuse (via a Chait tweet).
2. Three good ones from the folks at Mischiefs of Faction. First, Greg Koger's analysis of the Congressional vote on Syria is useful, whether or not there is a vote.
3. Then Jennifer Victor, also on the Congressional vote.
4. Also: Richard Skinner on why Republicans have flipped on foreign policy.
5. I like Kevin Drum's sentiment here about contemporary news cycles, but it's almost certainly hopeless; the best we can do is to remember that at worst things will seem messier in progress, but that doesn't mean that they'll now seem messier in retrospect.
6. And LGM asks the question: what photo should they put on their (hypothetical) annoying pop-up ad for themselves? Lots of excellent choices...but more to the point, who or what should Plain Blog have on our even more hypothetical annoying pop-up ad? I can think of a lot of good ideas, but even though it's not in good shape, I might well go with this one.
Plenty of good stuff:
1. Excellent new TNR feature: Isaac Chotiner tries to interview Barney Frank, receives abuse (via a Chait tweet).
2. Three good ones from the folks at Mischiefs of Faction. First, Greg Koger's analysis of the Congressional vote on Syria is useful, whether or not there is a vote.
3. Then Jennifer Victor, also on the Congressional vote.
4. Also: Richard Skinner on why Republicans have flipped on foreign policy.
5. I like Kevin Drum's sentiment here about contemporary news cycles, but it's almost certainly hopeless; the best we can do is to remember that at worst things will seem messier in progress, but that doesn't mean that they'll now seem messier in retrospect.
6. And LGM asks the question: what photo should they put on their (hypothetical) annoying pop-up ad for themselves? Lots of excellent choices...but more to the point, who or what should Plain Blog have on our even more hypothetical annoying pop-up ad? I can think of a lot of good ideas, but even though it's not in good shape, I might well go with this one.
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Don Murray, 84. Hey, he was in an "Apes" movie and an episode of The Single Guy; what else do you need?
And some good stuff:
1. Jordan Ragusa looks at the vote on the Amash (NSA) amendment.
2. First it was Nader; next, as Kevin Drum notes, it's Erick Erickson with the fantasies.
3. And the great Joe Sheehan on Bud Selig and the coming suspensions. Brutal, but he's right.
Monday, July 29, 2013
Catch of the Day
Great Ezra Klein item defending August recess. For Congress that is. As he points out, Congress for the most part is very much at work during what they try to call a "district work period."
I'm not sure that all 535 Members of Congress are intense hard workers, but in my first and second hand experience (I've known a fair number of people who worked on the Hill), not to mention what more careful research has found, the overwhelming majority work hard at their jobs. Doesn't mean they are all great at it; we've all known people who work hard but don't get anything done!
The one thing I'd add to Klein's piece is that legislative and committee staff are still busy at work during August. Okay -- not as busy, not even close, to how they are when Congress is in session. But it's not as if the business of legislating and oversight shut down when Members leave town; indeed, you'll find plenty of staff who will tell you that a lot of the "real" work happens when they can get Members out of their hair for a bit, and (even more important, perhaps) relax a bit from the minute-to-minute demands of committee hearings and floor debates. My sense is that this doesn't really apply so much to the long break after Congress adjourns before November in an election year until the new Congress begins in January (at least, if there's no lame duck session), but it very much applies to in-session breaks.
At any rate: nice catch!
I'm not sure that all 535 Members of Congress are intense hard workers, but in my first and second hand experience (I've known a fair number of people who worked on the Hill), not to mention what more careful research has found, the overwhelming majority work hard at their jobs. Doesn't mean they are all great at it; we've all known people who work hard but don't get anything done!
The one thing I'd add to Klein's piece is that legislative and committee staff are still busy at work during August. Okay -- not as busy, not even close, to how they are when Congress is in session. But it's not as if the business of legislating and oversight shut down when Members leave town; indeed, you'll find plenty of staff who will tell you that a lot of the "real" work happens when they can get Members out of their hair for a bit, and (even more important, perhaps) relax a bit from the minute-to-minute demands of committee hearings and floor debates. My sense is that this doesn't really apply so much to the long break after Congress adjourns before November in an election year until the new Congress begins in January (at least, if there's no lame duck session), but it very much applies to in-session breaks.
At any rate: nice catch!
Wednesday, June 12, 2013
Congress Gags Itself
I like this Kevin Drum item on NSA and oversight, but it repeats something which I think shouldn't be accepted so easily by everyone:
Granted: both the president and the bureaucracy can fight for the rules they prefer, too. But Congress, when they really want to do something, have plenty of tools to make it happen.
The reality here is that Members of Congress, with only a few exceptions, have been perfectly happy to gag themselves. To some extent that's because they approved of policies they didn't want publicity about, perhaps because they believe publicity would harm the consensus for those policies. To some extent it probably is because they are concerned about actual national security damage if secrets were publicized; that can be sincere even if it's wrong. But to a large extent, it's probably because pretending that they have no ability to do anything -- they can't even talk about it! -- is a very nice way of ducking responsibility.
I wrote something over the weekend saying that those upset about the NSA stories should be putting a lot of the blame on Congress, and this is yet another part of it. This is Congress's job. no one should let them off the hook with the excuse that they "have to" do what the NSA or the president says.
The traditional method of oversight is via congressional committees and the court system. But even if you assume that intelligence organizations are reporting their activities honestly, those don't really work anymore. Once a program is in place, courts end up rubber stamping virtually every application and congressional committees do pretty much the same. They simply become too accustomed to what's going on to truly pay attention. And in the case of Congress, even if some members do have issues, they're all but gagged from speaking out about them.Congress is gagged, yes -- but because they allow themselves to be gagged. It's not inherently up to the bureaucracy or the president to set the rules about secrecy. Congress can do that. And they do, either explicitly or implicitly.
Granted: both the president and the bureaucracy can fight for the rules they prefer, too. But Congress, when they really want to do something, have plenty of tools to make it happen.
The reality here is that Members of Congress, with only a few exceptions, have been perfectly happy to gag themselves. To some extent that's because they approved of policies they didn't want publicity about, perhaps because they believe publicity would harm the consensus for those policies. To some extent it probably is because they are concerned about actual national security damage if secrets were publicized; that can be sincere even if it's wrong. But to a large extent, it's probably because pretending that they have no ability to do anything -- they can't even talk about it! -- is a very nice way of ducking responsibility.
I wrote something over the weekend saying that those upset about the NSA stories should be putting a lot of the blame on Congress, and this is yet another part of it. This is Congress's job. no one should let them off the hook with the excuse that they "have to" do what the NSA or the president says.
Thursday, April 18, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Melissa Joan Hart, 37. I wonder if I'll wind up eventually watching her current show (she has one -- third season about to start, apparently). We've been watching Clarissa recently; still holds up extremely well.
Some good stuff:
1. An approach to studying legislation as it moves through Congress, from Scott Adler and John Wilkerson, that looks very promising to me -- plus a great illustration of just how many separate bills wound up on the ACA. Via John.
2. Alison Dagnes seems to be having a ton of fun writing about and teaching the invisible primary.
3. Recognize this? Name the US political figure who said it? "Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed." What if I spotted you that it's a president? Still no idea? Carah Ong on the 60th anniversary earlier this week of Ike's "Chance for Peace" speech.
Some good stuff:
1. An approach to studying legislation as it moves through Congress, from Scott Adler and John Wilkerson, that looks very promising to me -- plus a great illustration of just how many separate bills wound up on the ACA. Via John.
2. Alison Dagnes seems to be having a ton of fun writing about and teaching the invisible primary.
3. Recognize this? Name the US political figure who said it? "Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed." What if I spotted you that it's a president? Still no idea? Carah Ong on the 60th anniversary earlier this week of Ike's "Chance for Peace" speech.
Friday, April 12, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to David Letterman, 66. Our TV friend.
Good stuff:
1. All the Hastert Rule violations, from Derek Willis.
2. Kevin Drum reads GOP (or at least Chuck Grassley) reserve court-packing as an indication that they aren't going to confirm anyone to the DC Circuit court for the remainder of Barack Obama's presidency, at least not after the current nominee. I'm not sure; it could just be Grassley, who has been following a Hatch re-election strategy, looking to score points.
3. Jamelle Bouie, very good on Rand Paul at Howard.
4. The next step on health care? Sarah Kliff on the cost-cutting approaches wonks would like to see in the future.
5. Norm Ornstein on what's wrong with Congress.
6. And popularizing political science, from Joshua Tucker.
Good stuff:
1. All the Hastert Rule violations, from Derek Willis.
2. Kevin Drum reads GOP (or at least Chuck Grassley) reserve court-packing as an indication that they aren't going to confirm anyone to the DC Circuit court for the remainder of Barack Obama's presidency, at least not after the current nominee. I'm not sure; it could just be Grassley, who has been following a Hatch re-election strategy, looking to score points.
3. Jamelle Bouie, very good on Rand Paul at Howard.
4. The next step on health care? Sarah Kliff on the cost-cutting approaches wonks would like to see in the future.
5. Norm Ornstein on what's wrong with Congress.
6. And popularizing political science, from Joshua Tucker.
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Is "No Budget No Pay" a Misstep?
I highly recommend Stan Collender's latest on GOP budget strategy for those who aren't quite sure what a "budget" (that is, a Congressional budget resolution) is and why it does or doesn't matter.
I think I disagree with him, however, on the question of whether "no budget no pay" was a mistake for the Republican leadership.
Not on the part having to do with the Senate; I agree that pushing the Senate to pass a budget resolution is basically a waste of the House's time. But on the other hand, I don't think it matters much. Sure, if the Senate actually passes a budget resolution this year then Republicans will have lost a talking point, but (1) given that the talking point was nonsense I'm not sure it matters; and (2) even if the Senate is careful to be as vague as possible -- and they might not -- it shouldn't be hard to develop new talking points out of whatever they do. I'd call that part of it a wash.
No, the real advantage of "no budget no pay" has nothing to do with the Senate. It has to do with the House, where the Republican leadership has to balance between a bunch of Members who want to pass the most extreme budget possible and a probably larger group of Members who want nothing to do with it. The leadership, which needs the crazies and crazy fellow travelers from time to time, wants to give them their budget resolution...and "no budget no pay" will help them pass it. Or at least, it certainly should help.
More generally: there are plenty of things that Congressional leaders want Members to do that Members don't particularly want to do. In normal times, budget resolutions are probably one of those; Members want it done, but there's not much of an upside in voting for it. Whether intended or not (and I have no idea whether this was thought through or not), "no budget no pay" gives House leaders an extra weapon for keeping Members in line for what should be a tough vote. In my view, it's a terrible precedent -- legislators shouldn't have a personal stake in specific votes (I called it flat-out corruption last time I wrote about it). And I have no idea how strong an incentive it will turn out to be. But either way, if it has any effect I'm pretty confident it will be over on the House side.
I think I disagree with him, however, on the question of whether "no budget no pay" was a mistake for the Republican leadership.
Not on the part having to do with the Senate; I agree that pushing the Senate to pass a budget resolution is basically a waste of the House's time. But on the other hand, I don't think it matters much. Sure, if the Senate actually passes a budget resolution this year then Republicans will have lost a talking point, but (1) given that the talking point was nonsense I'm not sure it matters; and (2) even if the Senate is careful to be as vague as possible -- and they might not -- it shouldn't be hard to develop new talking points out of whatever they do. I'd call that part of it a wash.
No, the real advantage of "no budget no pay" has nothing to do with the Senate. It has to do with the House, where the Republican leadership has to balance between a bunch of Members who want to pass the most extreme budget possible and a probably larger group of Members who want nothing to do with it. The leadership, which needs the crazies and crazy fellow travelers from time to time, wants to give them their budget resolution...and "no budget no pay" will help them pass it. Or at least, it certainly should help.
More generally: there are plenty of things that Congressional leaders want Members to do that Members don't particularly want to do. In normal times, budget resolutions are probably one of those; Members want it done, but there's not much of an upside in voting for it. Whether intended or not (and I have no idea whether this was thought through or not), "no budget no pay" gives House leaders an extra weapon for keeping Members in line for what should be a tough vote. In my view, it's a terrible precedent -- legislators shouldn't have a personal stake in specific votes (I called it flat-out corruption last time I wrote about it). And I have no idea how strong an incentive it will turn out to be. But either way, if it has any effect I'm pretty confident it will be over on the House side.
Thursday, January 17, 2013
Read Stuff, You Should
Happy Birthday to Muhammad Ali, 71. Lots of great choices today, but certainly can't go wrong with The Greatest.
And just a little good stuff:
1. Sarah Binder on the Sandy vote and the Hastert rule.
2. The Voteview gang confirm it: the 112th was the most polarized Congress yet.
3. And a cute White House response to the petition for...impeaching Barack Obama.
By the way, I think I'm going to extend question day. I only did five yesterday, and there are lots of good ones remaining. So if you have one you didn't ask, feel free to post it now, although I can't promise to get to anything in particular, of course.
And just a little good stuff:
1. Sarah Binder on the Sandy vote and the Hastert rule.
2. The Voteview gang confirm it: the 112th was the most polarized Congress yet.
3. And a cute White House response to the petition for...impeaching Barack Obama.
By the way, I think I'm going to extend question day. I only did five yesterday, and there are lots of good ones remaining. So if you have one you didn't ask, feel free to post it now, although I can't promise to get to anything in particular, of course.
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Catch of the Day
I didn't get around to this one yesterday, but you know who earned one? Barack Obama, for batting aside a Jackie Calmes question about whether he socializes enough. After first explaining that "I like a good party" (which, true or not, sounded about as convincing as Graham Chapman's colonel protesting that "nobody likes a good laugh more than I do), Obama continued with a very nice riff on how presidenting really works.
I'm going to put the whole long thing below the fold, but the key quote? "You know -- and the reason that, you know, in many cases, Congress votes the way they do, or talks the way they talk, or takes positions and negotiations that they take -- it doesn’t have to do with me, it has to do with the imperatives that they feel in terms of their own politics, right?" Exactly.
Kevin Drum was pretty good on this, too, although his emphasis on the GOP as "zealots" is only part of the story. Even if Republicans were perfectly willing to cut deals, it's highly unlikely that Obama's (alleged) standoffishness would dissuade them from it.
The last bit of Obama's answer -- in which he hopes that the American people will rise up and demand Congress to cut deals -- isn't great; in real life, most people don't care about most issues, and the ones most likely to get all riled up are the partisans who are as likely to push their politicians away from compromise as they are to demand a reasonable deal. But overall, Obama gives about as good an answer on this one as possible. Now, if only reporters would start to believe politicians -- and scholars who study the presidency -- who have been telling us for decades that schmoozing just isn't all that important.
I'm going to put the whole long thing below the fold, but the key quote? "You know -- and the reason that, you know, in many cases, Congress votes the way they do, or talks the way they talk, or takes positions and negotiations that they take -- it doesn’t have to do with me, it has to do with the imperatives that they feel in terms of their own politics, right?" Exactly.
Kevin Drum was pretty good on this, too, although his emphasis on the GOP as "zealots" is only part of the story. Even if Republicans were perfectly willing to cut deals, it's highly unlikely that Obama's (alleged) standoffishness would dissuade them from it.
The last bit of Obama's answer -- in which he hopes that the American people will rise up and demand Congress to cut deals -- isn't great; in real life, most people don't care about most issues, and the ones most likely to get all riled up are the partisans who are as likely to push their politicians away from compromise as they are to demand a reasonable deal. But overall, Obama gives about as good an answer on this one as possible. Now, if only reporters would start to believe politicians -- and scholars who study the presidency -- who have been telling us for decades that schmoozing just isn't all that important.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)