Showing posts with label post-presidency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label post-presidency. Show all posts

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Titles

Did you see that the airport in Little Rock is being named after Bill and Hillary Clinton?

Putting aside the obvious jokes (which I made on twitter yesterday, but it fell flat, which is why I feel compelled to mention it again here) about why Arkansas is naming something after a New York politician -- perhaps this is a good excuse to push an idea that American politicians should, as Emily Yoffe argued in a terrific post earlier this week, act like Americans and stop using their titles after they leave office. See Paul Waldman's follow-up, too. Hey, even Walt Disney knew this one: the theater on Main Street shows "Great Moments with Mr. Lincoln," after all. In a democracy, Mr. or Ms. is a good enough title for anyone.

Back in the 1990s, I used to think that Bill Clinton was the right guy to start the trend. If he insisted on being Mr. Clinton now, I think there's a good chance it would catch on. But he didn't. Perhaps impeachment made him a bit more title-insecure than he would have been otherwise; perhaps it just never occurred to him.

Why Clinton? Well, it would presumably take a populist president to think of doing it...I wouldn't expect Ronald Reagan, for example, to have considered it. Nor would I expect it of anyone whose legitimacy as president was under fire: so not Nixon, or Ford, or Carter, or George W. Bush (and here's one case where it surely matters that Obama is the first black president; it would be entirely inappropriate to ask him to give up the title in the future while the other members of the ex-presidents club are using it).

Well, I hope he reads Slate (or the Prospect...well, I hope he reads Plain Blog, too, for that matter) and starts thinking about it. Surely by now impeachment is long past and his reputation as a legitimate president is safe and secure. After all, he's got an airport named after him! Maybe he could even get his buddy George H.W. Bush, surely secure in his reputation and with his own airport in Houston, to go along with it.

Yoffe is right: it's downright unAmerican to give people titles once they're done with their jobs. But she and I and you believing that isn't going to do any good. You know what we need? A Cincinnatus-of-the-titles, to take the lead and return to being a nice, citizenly Mr.

What about it, Mr. Preside...er, Mr. Clinton?

Thursday, January 20, 2011

JFK 50 and Post-Presidential Reputation

Robert Dallek has a nice article today in Salon about the puzzling post-presidential reputation of John F. Kennedy, who shows no sign of slipping in the public's esteem, even as fewer and fewer are around who actually remember him or voted for him.

Dallek also notes that Ronald Reagan does well in post-presidential polling, and attributes it to mainly to style, I think; he calls Kennedy and Reagan "master psychologists of the middle classes."

Perhaps. As usual, I lean towards institutional explanations, and to our old friend the one-sided information flow. As I've said before, four postwar presidents have had serious, sustained efforts to enhance their reputations. Two, Jimmy Carter and Richard Nixon, were essentially single-person efforts. The other two, Kennedy and Reagan, benefited from publicity campaigns on their behalf. That model seems to be the successful one, especially long-term. The result of that kind of campaign is one-sided information flow, because there's not much of any reason for anyone to waste their time agitating against an ex-president.

(Similarly it became logical for lots of reasons for New Dealers, including New Deal historians, to praise Woodrow Wilson, which in my view is the reason for Wilson's overrated reputation).

As far as I can tell, which presidents get this treatment is almost random. Kennedy happened to have a large, wealthy family and many talented staff and supporters interested in that sort of thing; that does sort well with what I think was a very personal presidency, but there are other personal presidencies that didn't generate much after the White House. Reagan had a conservative movement eager for a symbolic leader. Carter and Nixon just happened to care about their reputations, apparently, a lot more than, say, Gerald Ford or either George Bush seemed to.

I'm not sure where to place Bill Clinton. He's certainly tried to be visible doing good works, like Carter, but (and perhaps this is just my personal sense of things) Clinton seems a whole lot less self-aggrandizing than does Carter. Sure, WJC is campaigning for himself and his party; no question but that he's a born politician, and he'll never really turn that off. But it just doesn't strike me as similar to Carter's never-ending quest for sainthood. Clinton is also, almost certainly, the most partisan ex-president in modern times. (Ever? Could be). And then you have the unique so far situation of an ex-president whose wife has been a national-level politician; I don't know if that should be interpreted as part of Bill Clinton's publicity campaign, or as something that distracts from any efforts he might want to make to enhance his reputation.

Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Presidents Poll

I've seen several comments about the Gallup release yesterday detailing approval ratings for former presidents.  I'll add two things.  First, I'm always happy to see Jimmy Carter's reputation going down; he really was an awful president.  Second, it's no surprise at all that Kennedy and Reagan continue to get very high marks.  Four postwar ex-presidents have had serious campaigns to improve their legacy: Kennedy and Reagan had campaigns on their behalf, and Nixon and Carter basically campaigned on their own.  Of course, the former two were more popular while in office, but overall it does seem to me that if you really want your reputation to flourish, what you need to do is to get some serious institutional momentum behind the idea that you were a great president.   As always with public opinion on stuff like this, when what people hear is one-sided, it's apt to be pretty effective at moving the polling results.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Post-Presidential Reputation & Jimmy Carter

Greg Sargent flags a poll that gives Jimmy Carter high marks for his post-presidential career, saying:
[T]he numbers are noteworthy, because even before this week, Carter has generally been assumed by some Dems to be terrifyingly controversial, largely because of his writings on the Middle East.

With the focus on the Mideast heating up again, Carter will likely be making more news, and the Obama administration will likely be distancing itself from him again, as it did yesterday. Worth recalling that the public doesn’t take all that dim a view of the stuff he’s done since leaving the White House.

I don' t think that's a reasonable interpretation of the poll, however. Carter is one of four modern presidents who have benefited from a strong post-presidential reputation campaign. Well, one of the four, Nixon, didn't benefit very much from what was, in his case, largely a one-man operation. The two big success stories were the two organized by others on behalf of Presidents Reagan and Kennedy. Both presidents, as a result, are pretty significantly overrated in polls about past presidents (here's a good sampling).

The fourth story is Carter's. Carter, like Nixon, has pretty much run a one-man operation to improve his reputation. But Carter's "new" reputation is almost entirely separated from his presidency, and I think, almost entirely separated from issues of public policy. When people say they approve of Carter's post-presidency, I think it's almost certainly the case that they are thinking about building houses, serving as an election observer, and perhaps writing books of poetry and religious belief. I very much doubt that the first thing that comes to mind for very many people is Carter's views on Palestinians. They see good works, not good policy -- in fact, people still (correctly; I guess I should add a IMO) think he was a dud as a president.

Bottom line? I think Democrats would be well-advised to continue to keep as much distance from Carter as possible.

[Update]: Matt Yglesias makes a good point about this, too, plus he has a way better post title than I do.

Who links to my website?