Showing posts with label Democrats. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Democrats. Show all posts

Monday, April 29, 2013

Catch of the Day

It goes to Jamelle Bouie, who has a terrific response to the latest exercise in fantasy party history by the National Review's Kevin Williamson. As he says, it's based on
a heavily revisionist history of American politics, in which the GOP never wavered in its commitment to black rights, and the Democratic Party embraced its role as a haven for segregationists. In this telling of history, black support for Democrats is a function of liberal demagoguery and crude identity politics. If African Americans truly understood their interests, the argument goes, they’d have never left the Republican Party.
Williamson's focus this time is on a specific episode in Barry Goldwater's career. I have no idea whether Williamson is correct or not about it...it doesn't really matter. The point is that Williamson uses his anecdote in defense of, once again, his totally bizarre version of party history.

Bouie does an excellent job of briefly reviewing the real party history that Williamson, somehow or another, manages to ignore. Basically, Williamson still wants us to think that the Democratic Party was (and still is, but in disguise) nothing but George Wallace, and that the GOP was and still is nothing but Jacob Javits. He somehow or another manages to miss the epic battle between the segregationists and liberals within the Democrats -- and also misses the part in which civil rights Republicans were driven from their party.

Now, Williamson is trying to make Goldwater into a hero of civil rights, despite his vote against the Civil Rights Act. The point is that it really doesn't matter whether Goldwater was personally a bigot, or even a champion of civil rights on particular circumstances, or not. What matters is that the people who actually cared about civil rights supported legislation that Goldwater opposed -- and what matters far more is that over time the people who opposed civil rights lost their battle within the Democratic Party, but beginning with Strom Thurmond they found a home in the GOP. That's not to say that the GOP became a segregationist party; that would be taking it too far. But it's not only true that by the 1980s most opponents of the civil rights agenda wound up in the Republican Party, but also that the heirs of the civil rights Republicans really just aren't welcome in the today's GOP.

Seriously, it's as if Williamson just thinks that belief in the existence of Hubert Humphrey, Adam Clayton Powell, and other civil rights Democrats is sort of like believing in UFOs. He also seems to believe that it's necessary to recover the well-known facts about the old segregationist Democrats. As I've said before: it's perfectly reasonable to investigate the complicity of such figures as Adlai Stevenson and Franklin Roosevelt in that story. It just has very little to do with what was happening within the Democratic Party by 1964, and absolutely nothing to do with the Democratic Party by the 1980s, let alone the 2010s.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

What Will 2016 Dems Fight About?

I have a piece up at TAP trying to predict the issues that might divide Democratic candidates in 2016; yes, it's early, but as I say over there, if it's not too early to rank the candidates, why not also rank the issues? I'm not looking at the issues they'll run on, so much, but on those that might spark real disagreement. After all, in contested primaries, issues are one of the ways that candidates attempt to differentiate themselves from the pack. At the same time, while party-aligned groups may try to achieve consensus (as health care reform advocates basically did in 2008, or as marriage equality advocates will surely do in 2016), they also mayget candidates to compete for who has the best positions. And then, of course, party-aligned groups may disagree on what exactly is the best policy.

I picked climate, drones and terror, work and families, Pentagon spending, and agriculture/energy as likely topics for disagreement. In some cases (drones, Pentagon, perhaps energy) because the party really is divided; in others (climate, work and families, perhaps energy) because they're united on goals but unsure on the best policy to achieve them. Oh, and I'll probably do a list for the Republicans next week, either over there or back here.

So, what do you think? Did I get any of them wrong? What am I missing?

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

Sticking with the theme: what's a Christmas (or other appropriate holiday) gift that you would like to give to a Democratic or liberal leader?

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

Okay, I know that you're all excited about the prospect of Elizabeth Warren in the Senate, so you don't have to tell me about that one. But which other, if any, of the Democratic candidates for Senate do you have high hopes for if they win in November?

Sunday, September 9, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

I'll ask liberals the same question I asked conservatives last week: which speech at the Democratic National Convention, if any, deserved more attention than it received?

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Day 3 Preview

Just a couple thoughts, and then this can also be an open thread if anyone wants to comment during the convention. As I have the last couple nights, I'll be posting over at PP after they close up, and then most likely have further thoughts here after that. Oh, and I'll still be tweeting.

A couple things as the convention was just gaveled into order...

1. Kudos to the Democrats for doing the full roll call. Best moment: they passed to Ohio to put Barack Obama over the top. Because, you know, that's the thing that's really going to swing the general election. Especially since instead of doing it normally this afternoon or yesterday afternoon, they did it after Bill Clinton's speech last night, which as everyone knows ran a wee bit late. Also, it meant that I was trying to write my post-speech items during the roll call, and I got distracted and didn't hear whether South Dakota mentioned the Corn Palace or not. I did finished a bit before they did, and discovered when I looked up that the arena was practically empty by the time they got to Wyoming. So better to do it than not, but not exactly the best ever. Clear edge for GOP on that one.

2. As I check today's schedule, I notice that the most urgent choice they should make is to pre-emptively bump James Taylor from the schedule because they might run behind schedule later.

3. Oops. I'm writing this so slowly that he's already out on stage. I guess that nails down the PBS pledge break volunteers vote. Three songs? Weren't the guys from Tap available?

4. Anyway: if the Democrats asked me, my advice for the Joe Biden speech would be to have a foreign policy focus, and go as substantive and wonkish as possible -- bookending the Clinton focus on mostly domestic policy, and contrasting with the Republican ticket's historic lack of foreign policy and national security credentials.

So that's what I have for now. Oh, and apparently Gabby Giffords is doing the Pledge tonight, and Gabby Douglas did it yesterday. No idea who did it Tuesday -- who is the third-most-beloved Gabby, anyway?

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Democrats Day 1

I'm writing about the Michelle Obama speech, mainly, for PP (will add link when it goes up).  I think I'll handle some of the rest notes-style:

1. By tomorrow, I expect the Fox News/conservative talk radio version of this day to be that it was wall-to-wall bitter attacks on Mitt Romney's wealth and his patriotism. In fact, quite a few speakers used his overseas bank accounts as punch lines, and two speakers did in fact explicitly mention patriotism -- I think they both said "economic" patriotism -- so in those cases, they have a point. Of course, Republicans last week said that Obama was against the American dream, but regardless: the clips from tonight are going into the loop that reminds Republicans how hate-filled Democrats always are. Oh -- they're already giving that treatment to the Ted Kennedy memorial video, which detoured for a while into clips from the Kennedy/Romney Senate campaign. Apparently for some reason that's not kosher.

2. Wow, did they ever commit solidly on marriage! Presumably, the thinking is that it's an issue that's unusually good at motivating a very large chunk of very iffy voters to show up at the polls. Still, it seems to me that they would worry about scaring off the muddled middle who consider marriage a third-tier issue and wonders why that, and not jobs, is the focus.

3. I'm sure everyone is saying this (they did on twitter at least), but both the enthusiasm in the hall and the overall level of the speakers were clearly superior for the Democrats. You know what I'm going to say: be careful about giving too much weight to that. Remember first of all that most of it is invisible to most viewers (who only watch at best some of the broadcast network hour, and most likely see sound bites and interviews later), and also that most of us hear everything through a partisan haze -- so you need a lot less of a push if you're already leaning that way.

4. If conventions were about constructing a careful argument...my sense is that the Democratic "real people" did that more effectively than the Republican "real people" from last week. What the Republican real people were selling, over and over again, was that they had made it on their own and that they were insulted by a (mis) quote from Barack Obama. Leaving aside the dishonesty of it, the problem was that it didn't really give people a reason other then pique for supporting Romney; they didn't, generally, explain how specific Obama policies were harming them. Obama's real people all named specific Obama programs that had helped them, thus leading to a conclusion that you should vote for him.

5. Tonight's program was extremely Obama-centric. I mean, the parts that weren't bashing Romney. It was far more about Obama than about the Democratic Party. My sense is that the Republican convention was far less about Romney than the Democrats so far were about Obama.

6. None of the Democrats who tried call-and-response were very good at it. The champ? Ted Kennedy. But I suspect that if he tries it tomorrow, Bill Clinton will teach a master class.

Public Option? What's That?

Nope. The public option on health care did not make the Democratic Party platform. 

As Sarah Kliff explains, on health care the platform is mostly backwards-looking: there's a lot more of touting the achievements of the ACA than there are of new proposals for the future. There are some proposals for the future, however...but the public option isn't among them. It's fallen so thoroughly off the radar that Kliff doesn't even mention it.

Has there been any public policy proposal with a stranger path? In 2008, it was a minor point, one among many provisions in the comprehensive plans put forward by all the leading Democratic presidential candidates. It received little attention then. 

Fast forward a couple of years, and all of a sudden it is, for many liberals, the absolute core of health care reform, such that when it is defeated eventually in the Senate it's considered by many liberals a betrayal and a sell-out which makes the entire bill a mistake. 

I concluded from this that the long-term future of the public option was pretty good. Since it polls well among the general public and had intense supporters within the party, the odds were good that all viable Democratic candidates would support it; as long as that was the case, it would stand a good chance of being adopted the next time the Democrats help the House, the Senate and the presidency, at least assuming that the rest of the ACA was in place. After all, the public option can easily be grafted on to what would be in place then, and it can be passed on it's own through reconciliation. No need for 60 in the Senate.

And then...nothing. It's as if it never existed. Leading Democratic Senate candidates this cycle did not put it in the issue section of their web sites, even in liberal states with contested primaries where one would think that candidates would be looking for anything that appealed to liberals. And now it's not part of the party platform, and as far as I can tell no one really cares (Jon Walker at FDL does have an item today mentioning it; a quick search yields pretty much nothing else, and if there was any campaign to get it into the platform, it certainly didn't make very much noise).

I can think of lots of cases of an out-party caring passionately about an issue and then dropping it when they win. For a party, or at least the activists in a party, to begin caring passionately about an issue only after they are voted into office, and then drop it in time for the next election...that's weird. I don't really have any conclusions about it. I'm not sure I even have a theory. 

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

What's your favorite speech (or, perhaps, moment) from past Democratic conventions?

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

Same question: just for speaking ability, who are you looking forward to hearing at the Democratic Convention this year?

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

Elsewhere: Tribute to Newt, Blue Dogs Down

At Post Partisan, I take advantage of the end of the Newt Gingrich campaign to take several shots at the disgraced former Speaker. I did not, however, use the words "total fraud." Nor did I call him Tom P. Baxter. Restraint! But I did say several unkind things, as regular readers might imagine.

Over at Greg's place, meanwhile, I talked about the two Members who were defeated in PA Democratic primaries yesterday (one in a Member-Member race). My post there was about the upside for liberals in winning the spin on these races and therefore putting more pressure on Democratic Members of Congress to vote with them. I could also, however, talk about the downside -- nominating candidates who are bad fits for their districts. Calibrating these things correctly can be tricky! But whatever activists choose to do, my general point over there was that it's not just the wins, but also the spin, that matter.

Sorry for the slow blogging around here so far today, but I should be on a regular pace this afternoon, more or less.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

Catch of the Day

Excellent reporting from Aaron Blake, who notices that all seven of the candidates that Bill Clinton has endorsed in Democratic primaries this year supported Hillary Clinton in 2008, while in six cases their opponents endorsed Barack Obama.

Blake ends the piece by framing it around the question of how important Clinton's endorsement might be, but what I find far more interesting is whether we're seeing the beginnings of a more enduring factional split or not. I've done some research (with Casey Dominguez) that sort of touches on questions of factions within the Democratic Party, using data from way back in 2000...we were interested then, among other things, whether DLC involvement was relevant to the Gore/Bradley choice. The whole question of party faction, however, is still a fairly obscure one as far as I know, especially in the US context (explicit, well-organized factions have been important in some other democracies, but they don't really happen here). So the question I'd have is: could something that begins essentially as a personal faction in presidential politics wind up getting institutionalized and spread to state and local politics? If so, would it eventually develop policy components -- even though the original split didn't really have any?

My guess is that the answers to these questions is that on a theoretical level, this could happen. But in the present Democratic Party, it's very unlikely. Both of those, however, are just guesses...anyway, if you want to know what I find really interesting, it's this sort of thing. I'll almost certainly be looking out for it when the 2016 invisible primary gets underway (which, of course, isn't all that long from now).

Oh, and: great catch!

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Catch of the Day

Greg Sargent notes the upcoming controversy over what the Democratic platform will say about marriage. Good question.

I suppose I should note, before anyone jumps on it, that of course no swing voters will actually read the platform. Indeed, I suspect that marriage won't be an issue in the general election, at any rate. But that doesn't mean that people won't fight over the platform, nonetheless. And it's a legitimate fight. Everyone expects that by 2016 the Democrats will fully support marriage equality, but whether that happens or not has at least something to do with whether advocates press the issue. So don't expect them to back off just because everyone concerned wants Barack Obama re-elected.

I'll add one thing: it's going to be very tempting for anyone who is thinking of running for the 2016 nomination to get involved in this fight. We're expecting every 2016 Democratic candidate to support same-sex marriage rights, but this will be an opportunity not only to score points with organized groups, but to send a signal about liberal credentials to activists and party actors in general.

And: great catch!

Sunday, January 8, 2012

Sunday Question for Liberals

Same question as the conservatives got: How good a job do you think the Democratic partisan press -- MSNBC, liberal blogs, liberal talk shows if there are any -- has done of covering the presidential nomination process during this cycle? Are they helping you understand what's going on, or just having fun bashing the candidates?

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Sunday Question for Liberals

I've asked this one before, but it's been a while, and why should the conservatives have all the fun right now: who is your candidate for the Democratic nomination for president in 2016?

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

The Partisan Domestic Policy Gap

I really like this Matt Yglesias post in which he points out that George W. Bush's success with Congress is mostly a myth believed in by liberals. I'd add a couple of things. One is that the Republican House under Tom DeLay was, by all accounts, highly efficient in passing things that DeLay wanted to pass, which was an asset to Bush that he didn't earn...as long as he was doing things that DeLay wanted.

The second thing is that Yglesias accounts for some different outcomes by referring to differences in party discipline in the out-party: Bush was able to get cooperation from Ted Kennedy and Max Baucus, while Obama has thoroughly failed to get cooperation from Republicans; to the extent he succeeded, it was by compromising proposals to secure votes of the moderate fringe (Snowe, Collins, Brown), not by getting the active support of any mainstream Republicans.

I think that's true, but I don't especially think that it's interesting to think about why that is. I think the story that best explains it is about one perhaps asymmetry between the parties: Democrats are simply far more interested in policy, certainly in domestic policy (not the economy, but the rest of domestic policy), than are most Republicans. Ted Kennedy and George Miller were willing to cut a deal with George W. Bush because they were really, really interested in education. What, exactly, is Chuck Grassley really, really, interested in? I have no idea. Jon Kyl? No idea. I don't think there's a gap on foreign policy, at any rate not traditionally, there are some Republicans who have a strong domestic agenda, but I do believe there's a fairly big gap between the parties on it.

Of course, Republicans do care a lot about certain tax cuts, and Barack Obama was able to use that to cut a deal on taxes late last year. But what's the GOP agenda on health care? Education? Climate? There just isn't much of one -- either Republicans don't believe those things are problems, or they don't think that government can do anything. That's certainly a legitimate position (don't like it? Elect the other party!). But it makes it a lot easier for Republicans to maintain party discipline, and a lot harder for Obama or any Democratic president to cut deals.

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

Catch of the Day

David Freelander of the New York Observer, who talked to big Jewish Democratic fundraisers and found that -- shock and alarm! -- they're not abandoning Barack Obama after all. I think the key here is that the quotes sound as if they were scripted by the DNC, which in this case is very good evidence that Obama isn't in any danger of losing these folks. It's a fun article, and I recommend reading the whole thing...best bit?
[S]o far, only Haim Saban, the billionaire entertainment executive, has publicly declared that he was finished donating to the president. There was just one problem, though: Mr. Saban was a staunch supporter of Hillary Clinton and had never given money to Mr. Obama. Furthermore, Mr. Saban pledged to keep supporting down-ticket Democrats.
Via Greg Sargent, who adds:
I get that the campaign to paint Obama as anti-Israel is also about feeding a larger storyline, in which the Kenyan Muslim Marxist in the White House is hostile to a fellow western-style democracy struggling to survive against existential threats from Arab and Muslim foes.
Excellent point. I do think there's a bit more to it...as Freelander reports, there's probably an ever-widening gap between "professional Jews" and the rest of the politically active Jewish community, and the possibility that some of the reason that the press buys GOP spin on this is that a subset of Jews who think of themselves as mainstream and nonpartisan really have become part of the Republican party network. But I also think Greg's point is a good one.

And, great catch!

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Sunday Question for Liberals

Same question as the question for conservatives (see longish, probably dull preface there):

Which interest group in the Democratic party coalition do you think is most responsible for preventing the Democrats from being a true liberal party?

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Sunday Question for Liberals

Who would you like to be the next Speaker of the House? If the answer is Nancy Pelosi (b. 1940, so she just turned 71), who is your second choice?

Monday, April 11, 2011

What The Democrats Actually Did Wrong

Nothing new here, but it's worth emphasizing again where the Democrats did go wrong:

1. Failing to pass appropriations for FY 2011 when they had large majorities in Congress;

2. Failing to pass a large debt ceiling increase when they had large majorities in Congress;

3. Failing to even consider acting on DC Statehood when they had the votes to do it in 2009 (relevant here because apparently the tradeoff for saving ACA, EPA, and Planned Parenthood was allowing screw-the-District riders to survive).

Yes, the historic 111th Congress got a lot done, and much of what Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi did was impressive. But Democrats should have realized that the 111th was a rare opportunity to act and sacrificed district campaigning time and other competitors for (mostly) Senate floor time, and maximized the time spend passing their agenda. It was a clear, true, mistake, an unforced error, and the Democrats (and their constituency groups) are paying for it now.
Who links to my website?