Showing posts with label 2016 cycle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2016 cycle. Show all posts

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Elsewhere: Zombie Rubio, Budget Showdown, more

My TAP column this week was a caution flag to the press to stop burying presidential candidates too soon; my editor over there took a fairly dry piece and added zombies to the headline...and an awesome URL.

Today at PP I reminded everyone, again, that the bottom line in government funding negotiations is that eventually there will be a deal. I've made this point repeatedly, but I have a new formulation of it today: the choice isn't deal or shutdown; it's deal or shutdown and deal.

Let's see...earlier, I said that if there's a White House problem that needs to be fixed by personnel changes, it's a substance problem, not a spin problem.

More on the invisible primary, and one of my favorite topics, which is figuring out who is a candidate and who is not, this time pegged to Elizabeth Warren: my suggestion is to watch what they do, not what they say.

And I know I already linked to this one, but why not repeat it: the case for health care re-emerging as a normal political issue.

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Sunday Question for Liberals

Simple one: Who do you want to run for president? Not who are you supporting, but who do you hope runs?

Thursday, November 7, 2013

Please, Please, Please Giuliani Is Not a Christie Comp

Can we please get this stopped already? Chris Christie's presidential campaign is not at all similar to Rudy Giuliani's disastrous 2008 bid. Not similar. Not comparable. Okay? Just cut it out.

I'm seeing this all over the place, and it's just terrible.

Viable presidential candidates share two characteristics. They have conventional credentials, and they are within the mainstream of their parties in their positions on matters of public policy.

Granted, sometimes it's a bit tricky to judge. Did House Minority Leader Richard Gephardt have "conventional credentials" in 2004? No one from the House has been nominated in the modern era, but Gephardt himself in 1988 and Mo Udall in 1976 came fairly close. What about (General) Wesley Clark in 2004? But basically, we can look at the winners and all the candidates who came close from 1972 on and see if there's anyone similar. The more the comps, and the closer the comps, the better.

On mainstream views, it's hard to judge in any objective way what counts as sufficiently unorthodox to make a candidacy simply not viable. Almost every candidate has at least one issue position which is not embraced by significant groups within the part. And of course what the "party" thinks is, in part, exactly what's happening in the nomination process. Still, it's not impossible for outsiders to conclude that, say, Ron Paul was out of the GOP mainstream during his candidacies, or that Joe Lieberman's Iraq position was both far from the Democratic mainstream and extremely salient during his failed candidacy.

All of which gets back to Christie/Giuliani.

Giuliani failed both tests. One might argue for his credentials...I wouldn't. At least a couple of mayors have run for president before in the modern era, but none came close to winning. Generally, all the winners and almost all of the runners-up have had at least four years of experience at statewide elected office.

Christie, of course, is almost the classic case: elected governor, served a term, re-elected in a landslide.

As far as mainstream of the party: Giuliani easily failed that one. It's not really necessary to go past abortion, although in 2008 Giuliani was also on the wrong side (for Republicans, that is) on gay and lesbian rights when that issue was far more central to the GOP than it probably will be in 2016. There were more, including some where he had made not particularly convincing campaign conversions, but overall it just wasn't a close call.

Christie will have some problems on some issues with some GOP groups. It may be enough to derail his candidacy. But he's far more similar to Mitt Romney in 2012 and John McCain in 2008 than to Giuliani (or, say, Huntsman in 2012). He has problems, sure, but so do the other candidates. In other words, he may lose, but he's surely viable.

The various fiascoes of the Giuliani campaign were either irrelevant to the basic situation, or (as in his slow retreat from "contesting" states) a consequence of that basic situation -- that is, his claim that he was not contesting state after state was actually pretty much spin to cover the fact of losing in state after state. Therefore, they really don't apply to Chris Christie's situation at all.

Is Christie the frontrunner right now? I don't know. Is he a viable candidate? Sure. Does thinking about what happened to Giuliani help clarify Christie's situation? No. Not at all. Not even a little bit.

Just cut it out, everyone.

Friday, October 18, 2013

Why We Have Campaigns

Alex Roarty called Ted Cruz the 2016 Republican "frontrunner" today:
The Republican establishment despises Ted Cruz. And that’s great news for the senator from Texas: It’s the most prominent sign that he’s the front-runner for the GOP presidential nomination.
He also gets one good quote from Iowa conservative leader Bob Vander Plaats: “I really believe if the Iowa caucuses were held today, I don’t even think it’d be close. Ted Cruz would walk away with it.”

But here's the thing: it's not just a quirk of timing that the Iowa caucuses aren't being held today. What it means is that we're only at the beginning of a very long campaign.

And campaigns matter. Even general election campaigns matter; what they mainly do is remind people which party they belong to, and inform them that the nominee of that party is a perfectly acceptable representative of that party. That's a big party of why if you ask before the campaign you'll find all sorts of people ready to jump to a third party candidate, or in some circumstances even cross over to vote for the other party's candidate, but by November most people are back where they "belong."

In primary elections, the information environment is more complicated, because there are fewer obvious cues. Tail Gunner Ted is taking advantage of one of those cues right now -- he's been the most visible, recently, of the radical Republicans, so those who basically look for the representative of that strain of the party are moving to him.

Whether that lasts, however, is another story, as Michele Bachmann and Herman Cain could tell you.

What's going to happen is that Iowa voters will learn more about the various candidates. Recently they've had more exposure to Cruz; later, all the fully-funded candidates will get their own messages out. And, meanwhile, the press coverage will increase, both in the neutral press and the GOP-aligned media. And here's the thing: to the extent that GOP opinion leaders either hate Ted Cruz or, now, think that Ted Cruz is a loser, that's going to show up on the coverage that Cruz gets. Sure, not in all the coverage; there were, I'm sure, plenty of conservative blogs that were with Bachmann or Cain (or the Newtster for that matter) to the bitter end). But clearly enough to get the proper cues to a sufficient number of primary and caucus goers that they figured out: hey, that's not our candidate.

To the extent that those future negative cues are already baked in -- and I'm fairly confident that's the case for Ted Cruz -- no, he's not the frontrunner. Not at all.

Friday, October 11, 2013

Ted Cruz? Winnowed, Probably

I've been on the side of those who thought that Ted Cruz was a viable candidate for the Republican nomination in 2016. Not a likely winner, but very plausible.

I'm pretty sure that's done now.

I was willing to defend Cruz's chances despite his quickly-gained reputation within the Senate for excessively sharp elbows. I thought that Hill reputation was a relatively minor factor in overall party view of a contender.

But what's happened to him now goes well beyond Hill reputation. Moreover, the type of bad reputation has changed, and that should matter, too. Three things:

1. It's one thing to have a reputation as a loudmouth; it's quite another to have a reputation as a loser. That's what the shutdown fight has done to Cruz. Among true believers he'll be the one who was a leader in a fight that surely would have won if the squishes hadn't sold them out. But for most party actors, including many sympathetic to Tea Partyism, he's going to be the guy who ran up the wrong hill.

2. I can't remember if Grover Norquist had already publicly feuded with Ted Cruz before the shutdown fight, but he's certainly doing it now. That's not good. The more broadly Republican party actors dislike Cruz, and the more intensely they dislike him, the harder it would be for him to get the nomination. We saw the way this worked with Newt Gingrich in 2012: every time Newt stumbled, there were plenty of Republican opinion leaders ready to kick him while he was down. That's where Cruz is heading now.

3. Yeah, I think that the polling probably matters at this point. He's still fairly unknown, but I can't think of anyone who had established a 2-1 against ration on the favorable/unfavorable question eventually getting anywhere close to a major party nomination. Sure, it could still change, and I suppose one could argue that all it means is that the MSNBC audience has learned to dislike him...but then why hasn't the Fox audience learned to love him?

Add up all three of those, and at this point I think he's probably off the list of serious contenders. He still has the basics of a viable candidate (conventional credentials, if only just barely, and he's within the mainstream of his party on public policy positions). But I think it's extremely likely that he's in the process of being winnowed out.

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Counting Backwards (I Count You In)

Grover Norquist is pretty much right about the basics about the 2012 nomination process:
After the speech, he said only three of the Republicans seeking the nomination were really running for president: Mitt Romney, Tim Pawlenty and Rick Perry.

 “In 2012, we had ten people up on stage. Three of them were running for president, the others were looking to sell books or be radio talk-show hosts or marriage counseling or something, but they weren’t running for president,” he said.

Pawlenty, the former Minnesota governor, showed he was genuinely running for president because he quit the race when it appeared he couldn’t win, Norquist said. “The other guys, when they didn’t win, they didn’t quit because they weren’t actually planning to win,” he said.
Do I have a quibble? I do! They didn't make it to "up on stage," but Haley Barbour, Jon Thune, and perhaps one or two others might qualify as serious candidates. After all, they too dropped out when they lost.

Norquist anticipates that things will be different in 2016, with "six or seven" candidates having the money to compete.

It's certainly possible (although he seems to be implying they're stay in late into the primaries; that's not going to happen, since serious candidates who do badly in the early rounds will drop out after South Carolina or earlier). On the other hand, what may be happening on the Republican side is that the invisible primary is winnowing far more efficiently than it used to. It wouldn't shock me if we get half a dozen or so people who appear to be running now actually dropping out before the Ames straw poll, and then one or two more by fall 2015, leaving an Iowa field that looks sort of like the 2012 one -- two or three viable candidates, and a bunch of others.

What I'm also highly interested in is whether the same thing will happen on the Democratic side, or if they're pattern for at least formally announced candidates all making it to Iowa holds this time. If, that is, there are formally announced multiple candidates on the Democratic side.

(And, yes, I'm enjoying thinking about presidential nomination process stuff for a few minutes before I have to get back to the shutdown/debt limit topics. Oh well).

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Yes, the 2016 Campaign Is On -- But Stop Gaming Out Iowa

Yes, the 2016 nomination battles are on, and reporting on them is a great idea.

That said: let's not get ahead of ourselves. It's too early to game out Iowa, much less the events after that. It's too early to declare a candidate (say, Marco Rubio) has already lost his chance. It's not too early to say how policy positions are affecting the contest right now -- but it's still too early, for most issue areas, to have a real sense of how things play out in 2015 among party actors, and certainly too early in most cases to know how they play out among voters in 2016.

On the other hand, it's worth knowing which candidates are sparking intense interest among party actors, as well as which candidates are running into hostility from party actors (and yes, that might be the same candidate from different groups of party actors).

OK, so that's fairly tricky. And what makes it harder is that we really don't have a good roadmap. Yes, elite endorsements seem to matter, or at least they are good indicators of what's going on...but we really don't have any systematic way to predict whether it will be Cruz or Rubio or Kasich or whoever, or to explain why party actors go for one but not the other.

The upshot of that, in my view, should be caution. Gather and report as much information as we can, but be cautious about how to interpret it. Remember how few iterations of this process we've had, and even then it's hard to generalize across them because both the system and the parties have changed over time.

Again: reporting on what the candidates and party actors are actually doing is great. Some speculation based on that is fine. But try to remember that there's still a long time remaining, and the issue landscape changes all the time, and so do candidate apparent fortunes. Caution, everyone

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Sunday Question for Conservatives

Ted Cruz: helping himself get the Republican presidential nomination with what's happened on the shutdown, or hurting his chances?

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Yes, Of Course It's OK to Speculate About Syria and 2016.

This again? I'm hearing all sorts of complaints about people speculating about how the Syria matter will affect the 2016 elections.

If we're talking general election -- I'm with you. Pending an enormous policy disaster, and perhaps even if there is one, the outcome in Syria will likely have zero effect on the November 2016 election.

But if we're talking nominations? As long as you agree on two things:

1. The 2016 presidential nomination contests began some time ago and are underway right now; and,

2. The outcome of the 2016 nomination contests is important

...then of course it's reasonable to be talking about possible effects of the Syria thing on 2016.

Granted, some of that speculation will be foolish. Lots of punditry is foolish! But there's zero reason the topic should be off limits.

To the contrary: if you think the possibility of US intervention in Syria is an important one, then you absolutely should want to think about (and perhaps to attempt to affect) how the issue will play out within the two parties as a part of their presidential nomination processes.

I get that some people wish that there was a break from electoral politics. Sorry, it doesn't work that way. Not just in the US -- once again, parliamentary countries pick their party leaders far, far, in advance of the next election, and those selections are always open to further challenge, which means that they too have continuous party leadership competition, even though it takes a very different from. Parties do this for the very good reason that nominations determine who and what a party is, and in democratic parties that question is basically always going to be an open one.

To put it another way: speculating about 2016 (presidential nominations) is just another way of asking about a party's position on an issue, and perhaps in a deeper way than tallying votes in Congress might do. So if it annoys you, get over it.

Monday, August 19, 2013

Read Stuff, You Should

Happy Birthday to Jonathan Frakes, 61. Fire at will! Directed an excellent episode of Dollhouse. On the other hand: Sub Rosa. Fire at will!

Another week, another load of good stuff:

1. International treaties banning weapons...actually seem to work pretty well. From Charli Carpenter.

2. Ed Kilgore remembers Bert Lance.

3. Ezra Klein on young healthies and health insurance.

4. David Roberts on climate and conservatives.

5. Philip Klein is right about debates.

6. Josh Putnam on what, if anything, the RNC can do about debates it doesn't want.

7. And Reid Wilson introduces GovBeat. Excellent.

Sunday, August 18, 2013

Sunday Question for Liberals

I think I'll go with the same question. Presidential nomination debates, 2016: What would you like to see? Format, frequency, moderators -- what would you like?

Sunday Question for Conservatives

What would you like to see for the 2016 nomination debates? Format, frequency, moderators -- what would you like?

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Hmmmm...O'Malley

Alec MacGillis had a piece yesterday talking down Maryland Governor Martin O'Malley as a presidential candidate. He may be right! But...well, let me give you a taste:
For all his gym-rat, pub-rock credentials, O’Malley is not a very charismatic politician...

In speeches, this lack of dynamism becomes especially noticeable...

When attempting to explain a deeper rationale for his policies, O’Malley tends to offer long lists of metrics, or anodyne pronouncements like, “It’s not about whether we move left or right; it’s about whether we move forward or back.” He has a penchant for quoting, approvingly and at length, the bromides of Tom Friedman. It’s hard to see Democratic primary voters getting fired up about a candidate whose vision for the nation is of an “opportunity-expanding entity.”

But competence alone does not a national campaign make...
Okay, I'll buy all of that as weaknesses.

But it also sounds a whole lot like Mike Dukakis, who won a nomination pretty comfortably (it also could perhaps fit Mitt Romney). Now, granted, Dukakis got a drubbing from George H.W. Bush, but candidate qualities matter in the nomination stage, not the general election.

The more general question is whether we have any sense at all about what makes a good presidential nomination candidate. I've sort of played around with three tiers of viable candidates, mostly based on objective qualifications -- the top tier would be, for example, those with previous national success (so those who have been on a national ticket or run strong previous presidential nomination campaigns). Let's see...viable candidates, I've said, are those with conventional qualifications and issue positions within the mainstream of their party. So perhaps what breaks up the second and bottom tiers would be whether they fit comfortably within that definition or not.

 Subjective attributes? Forget it; there's just no way to have any sense of it.

What I do think is that reporters are apt to overemphasizing surface "campaigning" skills. They aren't irrelevant! But I'd always rather bet on a candidate who a broad range of important party actors like over a candidate who party actors have no demonstrated interest in despite the ability to give a rousing speech. On the other hand, figuring out what appeals to party actors is tricky indeed -- as is figuring out which party actors are the important ones.

And it's certainly true that, at least on the margins, one of the things that party actors may care about is electoral appeal, measured through performance on the stump and (ultimately) in presidential primaries. So I'm not saying that speechifying and other surface stuff is irrelevant. It's just easy to overstate its importance.

At any rate: O'Malley does seem to have one important qualification: he's eager and ready to run, full-out. That, plus basic viability, means I wouldn't write him off yet. At least not based on his campaign persona.

Friday, June 14, 2013

Read Stuff, You Should

Happy Birthday to Matt Freeman, 47.

Plus a little good stuff:


1. Josh Putnam's latest update on the 2016 calendar.

2. The Founders online? Cool.

3. And Ann Friedman on "the daughter problem."

Sunday, May 5, 2013

Sunday Question for Liberals

Yup, it's going to be about 2106, same as the question for conservatives. Interested in which 2016 possible candidates you find unacceptable, out of those who either are actively running now or at least getting frequent mentions. The list seems to be: Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden, Martin O'Malley, Andrew Cuomo, Kirsten Gillibrand, John Hickenlooper, Amy Klobuchar, Brian Schweitzer, Mark Warner, Elizabeth Warren, but feel free to add anyone else you don't like! So: which, if any, do you think are totally unacceptable?

Sunday Question for Conservatives

Yes, yes, yes, I know about it being too early for 2016 and all that, but nevertheless.

We have a very long list of potential candidates already, many of whom are actively doing the things that they would need to do to run; in other words, they're running right now. So my question: of all these candidates, which would you find completely unacceptable?

The list seems to include (and I'm trying to keep it fairly short, just the ones who seem at least semi-actively looking or have been frequently mentioned) Jeb Bush, Chris Christie, Ted Cruz, Jon Huntsman, Rand Paul, Rick Santorum, Marco Rubio, Bobby Jindal, John Kasich, Susana Martinez, Mike Pence, Rob Portman, Rick Perry, Paul Ryan, and Scott Walker. Which, if any, are on your unacceptable list?

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Yes, Ted Cruz Could Win the Presidency

This morning's big story was Robert Costa's report that Ted Cruz is actively running for president. Well, no one says it that way, but it's how I think of it. In Josh Putnam's formulation, whether or not Cruz will be running in 2016, he is currently running for 2016 by doing all the things that he has to do right now to be a viable candidate going forward.

At any rate, the early prognostication is that his chances are somewhere between slim and none. Jonathan Chait Dan Amira*, for example:
What are Cruz's prospects for winning the GOP nomination in 2016, and then the presidency? They are absolutely terrible.
Well, it's a two-part question. First, on the general election: yes, Cruz is likely to be perceived as an ideological outlier, but that's a penalty, not a disqualification -- it didn't, for example, prevent Ronald Reagan from winning. I'd guess that Cruz probably spots the Democrats two or three percentage points compared with someone with a more moderate image -- which matters, but is hardly the end of the story.

As a candidate for the nomination, the basics are that Cruz would be a minimally viable candidate: he will have conventional qualifications, if slightly on the skimpy side, and is probably more or less within the ideological mainstream of his party -- most of his dissent within the party appears to be more about attitude than issues, and if immigration winds up being his big issue he may well be more inside the mainstream than his opponents.

Will it matter that Republican Senators (reportedly) don't like him? It's not a plus -- Barack Obama, with similar conventional credentials, was surely helped within the party because Democratic Senate leaders vouched for him. On the other hand, Members of Congress are traditionally overrated within presidential politics. As for his general McCarthyite tactics, that's probably more of a plus than a minus among Republican activists, and perhaps even other Republican party actors.

That doesn't mean, of course, that Cruz is likely to win; it's far too long from now to then to really have a good sense of it. He is, for now, just another candidate. And, as with all viable nomination candidates, he'll have strengths and weaknesses that are revealed through the long campaign. But as far as I can see (and assuming that he's actually eligible for the office), there's no obvious reason to believe that he has no chance.

And pretty much anyone who could win a major party nomination has a reasonable chance of winning the presidency.


*My apologies for getting this wrong. Updated and corrected as indicated.

Friday, April 5, 2013

Ten Feet Tall

I completely endorse the distinction that Ed Kilgore makes but appears to feel isn't really necessary between "clear the field" and "dominant opening position" when talking about Hillary Clinton and the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination.

I think, that is, that the distinction is necessary. To me, "clear the field" means something pretty specific: that no other plausible nominee would run. So I wouldn't say that Al Gore in 2000 cleared the field; he solidly beat Bill Bradley, and it was probably over before the Iowa caucuses, but Gore had to run a real primary campaign against a candidate who certainly could have been nominated.

I mean, around the margins, I can imagine arguments...did George H.W. Bush clear the field in 1992 when Pat Buchanan ran? Did Richard Nixon in 1972, when two members of the House ran? But Gore clearly didn't. And my guess is that Clinton won't.

It seems to me this is quite a meaningful distinction, too. For one thing, it could affect whether she chooses to run or not. If she really could have the nomination without having to run through the primaries and caucuses...well, that's a lot easier decision than one that would involve defeating one or two or three candidates, no matter how heavily she would be favored.

I'm also not quite ready to conclude exactly how dominant she would be if she ran. Clearly, she's would be a heavyweight, top-tier, contender. But there's a long time to go, and it's not clear yet how Democratic party actors will think about this when they really have to commit. Basically, the reasons why she's an overwhelming apparent favorite right now -- she's well-known, well-liked, clearly qualified, clearly can raise money, and to some extent there may be a feeling that she's earned it -- may not turn out to be the things that actually yield her the overwhelming support of party actors in 2014 and 2015. I'm not saying that she wouldn't win, or even that she isn't an overwhelming favorite...I'm just saying I'm not sure yet. All we can say for sure is that she would be a heavyweight/top tier type candidate. Which is a lot, but not everything.

Monday, March 18, 2013

Primary and Caucuses Shuffle

The other big procedural reform discussed in the RNC party assessment document today is to shift the party convention back from August to July or June, and compress the primaries and caucuses further to make that work. In order to do that, they suggest that the party "should strongly consider a regional primary system or some other form of a major reorganization."

We should divide this into two parts. The date of the convention is fully within the control of the RNC, and if they want to move it, they can.

As Josh Putnam has been tweeting today, however, the dates of the primaries and caucuses are...a lot harder to control. The RNC would need the cooperation of state governments, and in most cases the Democratic Party, to do any sort of "major" changes -- indeed, even getting the states currently holding primaries in the first week of June to switch is awful hard to do.

Moreover, it's a bad idea! Whatever the weaknesses of the Republican Party these days, it's pretty hard to see how the flow of primaries and caucuses has worked against them.  Perhaps Ames and the pre-primary period -- it's possible to make a case that Mitt Romney, John McCain, and Bob Dole would have been replaced by better candidates if getting to Iowa was easier. But from Iowa on, it's hard to see where they've gone badly wrong, especially in this latest cycle. What's more, whatever one thinks of the GOP losing candidates over the last couple decades, at least the process allowed them to reach a decision with a minimum of fuss. There's no guarantee that a new schedule would work nearly as well.

Fortunately, we can treat that whole section as (perhaps misguided) hand-waving. There's no reform commission, there's no proposed schedule, there's no buy-in to any of the longstanding reform schedules that people have been pushing forever. So it's probably not going to happen.

As for the convention...the report claims that the convention needs to be 60-90 days after the last primary. That's silly. Most of the pre-convention planning doesn't really depend on the nominee; the rest doesn't take that long. The 1980 Republican convention began on July 14, with the final primaries on June 3; the 1992 Democratic convention began on July 13, with the last primary on June 9. Granted, in both cases the convention was locked up earlier, but that virtually always happens, giving the nominee plenty of time. A full month still gives them basically all of July for the convention.

On the other hand, there's absolutely no reason to think that it matters at all whether the convention is in June, July, August, or early September. The convention's purpose these days is to signal to party voters who haven't tuned in yet, or who supported another candidate in the nomination contest, that the party nominee has the full and enthusiastic support of everyone who matters in the party; it doesn't really matter a lot when that happens, as far as I can tell. And to the extent that conventions (if they're run well) produce an additional brief polling surge, it's hard to argue that there's any advantage for that to happen any time other than the week of the election.

(Typo fixed)

Could Postponing Debates Matter?

I'm going to look at the GOP presidential nomination process suggested reforms out today, starting with the debates.

The RNC wants to chop in half the number of primary-season debates next time around, starting later (not until September 2015) and ending earlier ("after the first several primaries").

It is worth noting this would mean that the first debate wouldn't be until after the Ames Straw Poll...and whatever one thinks of Ames, it's now become a regular pattern that one or more candidate is knocked out before the suggested date of the first debate.

If Republicans really were able to enforce both a ban on early debates and either a ban or at least a de-emphasis on early straw polls, it might -- might! -- mean two changes. Candidates who are fully in, but whose candidacies turned out to be duds, might well continue on into the fall...and perhaps if they make it to October, they might stick around until Iowa just in case lightning strikes.

On the other hand, the lack of any clear markers (debates, straw polls) early in the process might encourage candidates to extend the half-in/half-out period that, say, Sarah Palin managed to milk for months in the run-up to 2012.

So...I'm not exactly predicting any of these things happening. First of all, the RNC said nothing about Ames, although there has been a fair amount of Ames-bashing previously. Second of all, there are good reasons that early debates and straw polls happen. The press wants them, most definitely including the partisan press. Longshot candidates want them. Crank candidates (that is, those who are running not for the nomination but for a contract with Fox News or a radio show) want them. The sponsors/hosts want them. So whatever the merits, it's not at all clear that the RNC will succeed in getting those early markers delayed closer to the election year.

And second, it's not entirely clear exactly why Republican candidates have been exiting before Iowa, anyway. I do believe it's real, and a fairly big deal, and has to do with candidates realizing that their chances are very slim. It's a lot harder to know, however, exactly how that works, and therefore how changing the architecture of the year before the primaries will actually change things.

It's also not at all clear that the Republican Party would have been better off if Tim Pawlenty, Dan Quayle, Liddy Dole, Pete Wilson, and others had made it to Iowa.

At any rate, getting back to debates...if the natural tendency of debates is to keep spreading, then perhaps it's worth it for the RNC to fight back -- not so they'll actually get whatever they think is their perfect debate schedule, but in order to control the spread some.
Who links to my website?